Chapter 29: Just a Cat and a Barnacle

Tuesday. Or what Andy had decided was a Tuesday.

Andy guessed it was a Tuesday because after all, he was a horse. He had no real sense of time or how time worked in this universe. But for his old-self it helped him to quantify the days into words that made sense. And so it was a Tuesday.

He had been watching the feline for weeks. His life-sense tracked the creature automatically, the horn’s passive awareness cataloguing its recovery with the clinical thoroughness of a vet tech monitoring a patient in the ICU, except the ICU was a clearing and the patient in question was a Tier 5 apex predator that weighed more than Andy. She, Andy had noted reluctantly, also had teeth designed for things Andy’s neck preferred not to think about.

Recovery had been steady. His healing aura did the work, golden glow seeping into the feline’s biology during every hour they shared the clearing, and the chimera scars had faded from raw to pink to thin white lines that his eyes could barely see. The feline ate (deer-analogs that wandered too close to the clearing’s edge and discovered that a healing aura did not extend to diplomatic immunity from apex predators). And she slept (in the sunny patch by the stream, always the sunny patch from mid-morning to early evening. She seemed to have claimed said sunny patch with the territorial commitment of a creature who had found and claimed the perfect napping coordinates and was not interested in alternatives). She existed and recovered in Andy’s clearing with the calm, unhurried presence of a large cat that had found a comfortable situation, zero predators and an abundance of food. In other words she saw no reason to leave and he was in-cat-pacitated.

Andy had tried to talk to it. Every day. His telepathic projection, which could reach Veronica from fifty meters and hit Teeth from across the clearing and occasionally blast Gustave at altitudes the hawk found personally offensive, washed over the feline like warm water over a stone. Present. Received. Not acknowledged.

She heard his broadcasts the way she heard birdsong: as sound. Without language or meaning. Just ambient noise in a clearing that was full of ambient noise, most of it produced by a glowing horse whose magical output made the local flora bloom and the local fauna relax and the local crustacean (downstream, filtering, classified) do whatever Barnacle did when exposed to sustained life magic at close range.

“Good morning,” Andy projected at the feline on the (probably) Tuesday she left. The projection carried warmth, care, the gentle emotional bleed of a creature that could not stop broadcasting affection at everything within range.

The feline’s ear rotated toward him. One ear. The other ear was tracking a beetle. The beetle won the attention contest, and her eyes turned away from Andy’s telepathic greeting to follow the beetle’s path across a leaf, pupils dilating with the focused intensity that cats reserved for things that moved.

Andy had spent days trying to form a party bond with this creature.

Credit to the System: it had been patient about it.

[PARTY INVITATION: DENIED. (ATTEMPT 37.) REQUIREMENTS NOT MET: NO CONSCIOUS INTENT TO ASSOCIATE. THE FELINE DOES NOT PARTY. THE FELINE COEXISTS. THESE ARE DIFFERENT VERBS.]

“I know they’re different verbs,” Andy said.

[THE SYSTEM IS ENSURING CLARITY. THE EQUINE HAS SUBMITTED 37 PARTY INVITATIONS TO AN ORGANISM THAT DOES NOT UNDERSTAND THE CONCEPT OF A PARTY. THE SYSTEM ADMIRES THE PERSISTENCE. THE SYSTEM ALSO NOTES THAT PERSISTENCE AND FUTILITY ARE NOT MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE.]

“Thank you, System. Very helpful.”

The fox, from her rock, sent an impression that was equal parts amusement and exasperation, the specific blend Teeth produced when Andy was doing something she had told him not to do and was doing it anyway. She still doesn’t understand you. She’s still just a cat.

“She’s Tier 5,” Andy projected. “You’re Tier 4. Gustave is Tier 4. Both of you communicate. Both of you have opinions about my gallop efficiency and my horn volume and my apple consumption habits. This cat is a higher tier than either of you and it can’t form a sentence. Also I’m going to call you Teeth since you don’t have a name.”

First of all, Teeth projected exasperation although amusement tickled the edges. The only reason I have opinions about your horn is because it’s loud. I wouldn’t give your horn a second thought otherwise. Secondly I don’t need a name. Thirdly, being a high tier does not equate with sentience, I have explained this.

“You’ve said it. You haven’t explained it.”

Teeth stood on her rock. Stretched, the deliberate full-body extension of a fox deciding to invest effort in a conversation she had been deferring. Through the bond: resignation, affection, the exasperated warmth of a creature preparing to teach something she considered obvious. Like an adult teaching a baby to walk.

You evolved through choices, she sent. Every tier, the System gave you a menu. You picked. For whatever reason– Spike over shell. Jellyfish over worm. Frog over fish. Horse over… anyway you get my point. Your consciousness shaped your evolution because your consciousness was part of the process. You were at every fork in the road, making decisions.

She looked at the feline. The feline was now lying on its back with all four paws in the air, which was either a display of territorial comfort or an advanced yoga position.

The cat has never made a choice. The cat lived. The cat hunted. The cat survived long enough for the System to move it up a tier, and then another, and then another. No menus. No “do you want to be a jellyfish or a worm?” The System measured its life and its life took shape based on the personality traits the cat had. And so, she got bigger and faster and more magical and at no point in that process did anyone ask the cat what it wanted to become. She never developed a consciousness more than a magical beast.

“So sentience is about choosing?”

From above, Gustave’s impression arrived with the clipped authority of a raptor who had been listening and had decided the fox’s explanation, while adequate, lacked precision: Sentience is not able to be developed. It simply is or it isn’t. A beast may arrive with sentience and it may not. Perhaps it has to do with who or what it had been prior to being what it started as. Perhaps the system thinks it’s funny to make certain sapient creatures bugs and others hamsters and others humans and watch what happens to them. Humans, cannot evolve. They have no tiers. They don’t know the system. So given this feline cannot accept a party invite, nor can she understand you it stands to reason that she is not sapient and will never have the cognitive capability of speech. Or anything more than a very dangerous pet.

“So the System doesn’t care if you’re sapient or not?”

The System doesn’t care. The system has parameters and allows beings to function within them. It does not dictate outcome, nor does it interfere. Beasts gain experience. Beasts level. The only difference between sentience and not is that one develops the ability to have opinions about the process. The System does not prefer one over the other.

Andy looked at the feline. Paws still in the air. Eyes closed. The epitome of a creature that had evolved toward hunting and napping and had achieved mastery in both.

“How does XP work for them? If they don’t have menus, don’t choose their path, don’t make decisions, how do they gain XP?”

Living, Teeth sent. Hunting. Surviving. Every creature in the System accumulates through existing. You gain XP from kills and training and speed trials because your build tracks those metrics. The feline gains XP from being alive in a competitive ecosystem. Eating prey. Defending territory. Enduring seasons. The System measures the life and awards accordingly.

The rate varies by species and activity, Gustave added. To balance prey typically gain XP at a higher rate than predators. The System rewards engagement with the environment. What it does not reward is passivity. A pause. Barnacle is the exception. Barnacle’s accumulation remains classified, which suggests the System has categories we do not have access to.

“So Barnacle…”

Do not ask about Barnacle, Teeth sent. That way lies madness and classified information.

Andy filed it. Filed all of it. Tier was not sentience. Choices made the person. The System was a framework, not a sculptor. Most creatures in this world were the feline: alive, powerful, evolving, and as intellectually complex as Gerald on a warm afternoon.

He had projected himself onto this creature. During the chimera fight, standing over a corrupted Tier 5 predator with violet energy burning through its body, he had seen a prisoner. A person trapped inside corruption, suffering, aware of its own suffering, waiting for rescue. He had drained his horn to zero because he believed the creature inside was someone worth freeing.

Help support creative writers by finding and reading their stories on the original site.

What he had freed was not a someone. It was a cat. A beautiful, powerful, healing cat that slept in sunbeams and caught beetles and would never, in any tier of its existence, understand what Andy had done for it or why.

Saving it still mattered. Andy’s vet-tech brain confirmed this with the certainty it brought to every clinical assessment: a life did not need to be conscious to be worth preserving. He had treated hundreds of animals at the clinic. Dogs, cats, iguanas, a parrot named Kevin who could say “I am become death” and nothing else. None of them had been sapient. All of them had been worth treating.

“I thought saving it would feel different,” Andy projected at Teeth. “I thought we’d have a new party member. A Tier 5 feline with teeth and claws and the kind of combat capability that would make the Binder think twice. Instead I have a very large cat that naps in my clearing and does not know my name. And every few days leaves a carcass by where I sleep.”

Not every rescue produces a friend, Teeth sent. Some produce a patient. You healed her and kept safe. She does not owe you a personality for your troubles.

This landed harder than Andy expected. He was quiet for a minute. His horn pulsed gold in the morning light, the moonlight-class luminescence muted by daylight but still present, still broadcasting his emotional state to the clearing. The broadcast, at this moment, was: a complicated mixture of acceptance and old grief that had nothing to do with the feline and everything to do with a cat named Gerald who had eaten butter from the dish and whom Andy had loved without reservation. Regardless of the fact that never once, in their entire relationship had Gerald sent a telepathic impression or joined a party or done anything other than exist in the same space as Andy.

Gerald had been enough.

This feline was enough too. Even without sentience or a party. Even without ever knowing the name Andy Snodgrass or the concept of evolution (the meaning from either universe) or even, the word “unicorn.”

She stood up on the (maybe) Tuesday afternoon. Stretched. Walked to the edge of the clearing with the unhurried confident swagger of a predator that had healed and now would go elsewhere. It paused at the treeline. Its amber eyes, clear now, no trace of corruption, looked back at the clearing. At the sunny patch. At the stream. At Andy, who was standing with his horn casting golden light and his heart doing the thing it did when patients left the clinic: the specific ache of a caretaker watching something healed walk away.

No impression. No nod, no bow, no acknowledgment. It looked at the clearing the way cats look at places they have decided they are finished with: brief, total attention, and then with none. It turned and walked into the forest with the easy, muscular grace of a Tier 5 predator whose body was whole and whose instincts pointed elsewhere.

Gone.